Home⇛DAVAO RESEARCH JOURNAL⇛vol. 15 no. 1 (2024)

Breaking down the enigma of out-of-field research teaching among private senior high schools in Davao City, Philippines: A transcendental phenomenological inquiry

Orville J Evardo Jr.

Discipline: Education

 

Abstract:

Subject matter expertise goes far beyond simply knowing and regurgitating facts. It is a multifaceted ability encompassing a deep understanding of the content, pedagogical knowledge, assessment proficiency, fostering critical thinking and problem-solving skills, and cultivating positive attitudes and values. This transcendental phenomenological study was conducted to understand the lived experiences of SHS out-of-field research teachers in terms of assignment, instruction, and feedback. To grasp the phenomenon’s essence, transcendental phenomenology aims to set aside the researcher’s preconceived ideas and strive for neutrality. The study was participated by 14 teacher-participants from the selected private senior high schools in Davao City, Philippines. Findings show that in terms of assignment, participants’ experiences include adherence and submission to school administrators, consideration of teacher potential, experience, and training, and feelings of anxiety and frustration. With regards to instructional experiences, it includes lack of experience, aptitude, and administrative support; difficulty in establishing authority and checking outputs. With these challenges, participants must be resourceful and creative and engage in professional development activities. In terms of feedback, participants were honest and open-minded and experienced the welcoming nature of the students. The findings elaborate on the complex and multi-faceted nature of out-of-field teaching, which is expected to inspire improved teacher hiring and placement policy. It is recommended that educational institutions should provide professional development programs to help those out-of-field teachers stay updated with best practices.



References:

  1. Ahmed, A.   T.,   and   Shogbesan, Y.   O.   (2023).   Exploring           Pedagogical           ContentKnowledge   of   Teachers:   A   Paradigm   for MeasuringTeacher’sEffectivenessPedagogi: Journal     Ilmu     Pendidikan, 23(1), 64-73.
  2. Ahea,   M.   M.   A.   B.,   Ahea,   M.   R.   K.,   and   Rahman,      I.      (2016).      The      Value      and    Effectiveness    of    Feedback    in    Improving    Students’    Learning    and    Professionalizing   Teaching   in   Higher   Education. Journalof   Education   and   Practice, 7(16), 38-41.
  3. Antoniou,   P.,   and   Kyriakides,   L.   (2013).   A   dynamic      integrated      approach      to      teacher      professional      development:      Impact     and     sustainability     of     the     effects        on        improving        teacher        behaviour     and     student     outcomes.     Teaching   and   teacher   education,   29,   1-12.
  4. Bakker,   A.,   and   Akkerman,   S.   (2019).   Thelearning      potential      of      boundary      crossing  in  the  vocational  curriculum.  The    Wiley    handbook    of    vocational    education      and      training,      349-372.
  5. Bayani,   R.   T.,   and   Guhao   Jr,   E.   S.   (2017).   Out-of-field  teaching:  Experiences  of non-Filipino      majors.      International      Journal    of    Education,    Development,    Society  and  Technology,  5(11),  91-127.
  6. Braun, V., and Clarke, V. (2006). Using thematicanalysis    in    psychology.    Qualitative    research   in   psychology,   3(2),   77-101.
  7. Briggs,  F.  L.  (2018).  An  examination  of  the  literacy  practices  of  high  school  social  studies  teachers.  Salisbury  University.
  8. Bugwak,  E.  (2021).  Travails  of  out-of-fieldteachers:  A  qualitative  Inquiry.  Journal of   World   Englishes   and   Educational   Practices, 3(2), 36-57.
  9. Schleicher,   A.   (2021).   Learning   from   the   Past,  Looking  to  the  Future:  Excellence  and       Equity       for       all:       Andreas Schleicher;OECD.
  10. Catalana,     S.     M.     (2020).     Indicators     of     impactful  reflection  in  pre-service teachers:  A  case  for  creativity,  honestyand    unfamiliar    experiences.    Inter-national   Journal   for   the   Scholarship   of   Teaching   and   Learning,   14(1),   14.
  11. Cohen, L., Manion, L., Morrison, K., and Wyse, D.  (2010).  A  guide  to  teaching    practice.    Routledge.
  12. Cortes, S. T., Pineda, H. A., and Jugar, R. R. (2022).Alignment   of   the   revised   secondaryteacher education  curriculum  and  the  hiring  qualifications  for  SHS  teachers in   the   Philippines:   a   theoretical   gap   analysis. Journal       of       Education       Naresuan      University,      24(1),      1-14.
  13. Darling-Hammond,  L., & Bransford, J. (Eds.).(2007).Preparing teachers for a changing world:   What   teachers   should   learn   and  be  able  to  do.  John  Wiley  &  Sons.
  14. Darling-Hammond,  L., & Youngs, P. (2002). Defining “highly qualified teachers”: What does  “scientifically-based  research” actually tell us?. Educational researcher, 31(9), 13-25.
  15. Darling-Hammond,  L., Burns, D., Campbell,C., Goodwin, A. L., Hammerness, K., Low,   E. L., and Zeichner, K. (2017). Empowered  educators: How high-performing systems    shape    teaching    quality  around  the  world.  John  Wiley  & Sons.
  16. Delve,   Ho,   L.,   and   Limpaecher,   A.   (2020,   August    31).    How    to    Do    Thematic    Analysis.   Essential   Guide   to   Coding   Qualitative Data.
  17. Dös,  I.,  and  Savas,  A.  C.  (2015).  Elementary School     Administrators     and     Their     Roles    in    the    Context    of    Effective    Schools. Sage Open, 5(1), n1.
  18. Education Commission. (2019). Transforming the    education    workforce:    Learningteams  for  a  learning  generation.  New  York: Education Commission.
  19. Ford, T. G., Urick, A., and Wilson, A. S. (2018).Exploring the effect of supportive teacher evaluation  experiences  on  US  teachers’  job     satisfaction.     Education     policy     analysis archives, 26, 59-59.
  20. Geiger,  T.,  and  Pivovarova,  M.  (2018).  Theeffects of working conditions on teacher retention. Teachers and Teaching, 24(6), 604-625.
  21. Gist, C.  D.  (2022).  Shifting  dominant  narrativesof       teacher       development:       New       directions    for    expanding    access    to    the  educator  workforce  through  grow  your     own     programs.     Educational Researcher, 51(1), 51-57.
  22. Girvan,   C.,   Conneely,   C.,   and   Tangney,   B.(2016).  Extending  experiential  learning  in   teacher   professional   development.   Teaching     and     teacher     education,     58, 129-139.
  23. Graham,  L.  J.,  White,  S.  L.,  Cologon,  K.,  andPianta,  R.  C.  (2020).  Do  teachers’  years  of   experience   make   a   difference   in   the    quality    of    teaching?    Teaching    and   teacher   education,   96,   103190.
  24. Higgins,    J.,    and    Parsons,    R.    (2009).    A    successful    professional    development    model  in  mathematics:  A  system-wide  New  Zealand  case.  Journal  of  teacher  education, 60(3), 231-242.
  25. Hobbs, L. (2015). Too many teachers teachingoutside   their   area   of   expertise.   The Conversation, 13.
  26. Hobbs, L., and Quinn, F. (2021). Out-of-field teachers  as  learners:  Influences  on teacher      perceived      capacity      and      enjoyment over time. European Journal of   Teacher   Education,   44(5),   627-651.
  27. Hobbs,  L.,  and  Törner,  G.  (2019).  Teaching  out-of-field  as  a  phenomenon  and research     problem.     Examining     the     Phenomenon of “Teaching Out-of-field” International  Perspectives  on  Teaching  as a Non-specialist, 3-20.
  28. Johnson,     B.     (2015).     Creative     teacher”     is not an oxymoron.
  29. Lavrič, A. (2006). Teachers’ reflections on theirattitude toward  students.  In  Proceedingsof  the  31st  Annual  ATEE  Conference:  Co-operative   Partnerships   in   Teacher   Education.  Retrieved  at    Sprinthall,  NA  &   Sprinthall,   RC   (1990).   Educational   psychology: A developmental approach. (5thed.).     McGraw-Hill     International     Editions.
  30. Lee-Chua, Q. N. (2012). Preparing teachers for the big reform. Philippine Daily Inquirer.
  31. Lenhoff,   S.   W.,   Singer,   J.,   Pogodzinski,   B.,and   Cook,   W.   (2022).   Exiting   Detroit   for    school:    Inequitable    choice    sets    and      school      quality.      Journal      of      Education         Policy,         37(4),590-612.
  32. Lopez,  H.,  and  Roble,  D.  (2022).  Challengesand     adaptive     strategies     of     out-of-field   mathematics   teachers   in the    province    of    Misamis    Oriental    Philippines. American      Journal      of      Educational   Research,   10(3),   111-115.
  33. Merriam,   S.   B.,   and   Tisdell,   E.   J.   (2015).   Qualitative     research:     A     guide     to     design     and     implementation.     John Wiley & Sons.
  34. Moustakas,    C.    (1994).    Phenomenological    research   methods.   Sage   publications.
  35. Nguyen,  H.  T.  M.,  and  Ngo,  N.  T.  H.  (2018).  Learning  to  reflect  through  peer mentoring    in    a    TESOL    practicum.    Elt Journal, 72(2), 187-198.
  36. OECD.        Publishing.        (2005).        Teachers        matter:          Attracting,          developing          and      retaining      effective      teachers.      Organization             for             Economic             Co-operation        and        Development.
  37. Pit-ten      Cate,      I.      M.,      Markova,      M.,      Krischler,    M.,    and    Krolak-Schwerdt,    S.       (2018).       Promoting       Inclusive       Education:    The    Role    of    Teachers’    Competence    and    Attitudes.    Insights into  Learning  Disabilities,  15(1),  49-63.
  38. Podolsky,    A.,    Kini,    T.,    Bishop,    J.,    and    Darling-Hammond,   L.   (2016).   Solving   the  teacher  shortage:  How  to  attract  and      retain      excellent      educators.      Learning Policy Institute.
  39. Přibylová,  J.,  Smetanová,  V.,  Machek,  J., Kožnarová,  M.,  &  Knaute,  L.  (2015). Psychological        needs,        level        of        frustration   and   anxiety   of   teachers   at     primary     school.     Procedia-Social and   Behavioral   Sciences,   171,   1114-1117.
  40. Ríordáin,  M.  N.,  Paolucci,  C.,  and  O’Dwyer, L.  M.  (2017).  An  examination  of  the  professional    development    needs    of    out-of-field   mathematics   teachers. Teaching   and   Teacher   Education,   64, 162-174.
  41. Reyes,  J.,  Insorio,  A. O., Ingreso,  M.  L. V., Hilario, F. F., and Gutierrez, C. R.   (2019).Conception    and    application  of contextualization in  mathematics   education. International  Journal  of  Educational  Studies    in    Mathematics,6(1), 1-18.
  42. Shah,   C.,   Richardson,   P.   W.,   Watt,   H.   M.,   and     Rice,     S.     (2022).     ‘Out-of-Field’Teaching   in   Mathematics:   Australian   Evidence   from   PISA   2015.   In   Out-of-field   teaching   across   teaching disciplines   and   contexts   (pp.   71-96).   Singapore:  Springer  Nature  Singapore.
  43. Shulman, L. S. (1986). Those who understand: Knowledge      growth      in      teaching.      Educational    researcher,    15(2),    4-14.
  44. Symeonidis,     V.     (2015).     The     status     of     teachers  and  the  teaching  profession.  Education       International       Research       Institute: Belgium.
  45. Salzano,  C.,  and  Labate,  H.  (2016).  Teaching  policies    and    learning    outcomes    in    Sub-Saharan Africa: issues and options.
  46. Uzun,    T.,    and    Ozdem,    G.    (2017).    The    Mediating  Role  of  Job  Satisfaction  on  the    Relationship    between    Teachers’    Perceptions    of    Supervisor    Support    and   Job   Performances.   International Journal  of  Educational  Administration  and      Policy      Studies,      9(7),      84-90.
  47. Waters, J. (2016). Phenomenological research guidelines. Capilano University.
  48. Zhao, Y. (2012). World class learners: Educatingcreative  and  entrepreneurial  students.Corwin Press.

Tools


Copyright © 2024  KITE Digital Educational Solutions |  Exclusively distributed by CE-Logic